Research Goal
Design one difficult but fair browsing challenge.
Web research • AI evaluation • Benchmark design
A difficult, objectively verifiable research problem with independently checkable clues and a complete evidence trail.
This independent portfolio project demonstrates how I construct and validate research challenges designed to test the limits of AI browsing agents. The benchmark below is complete: the answer is fixed, every clue is tied to a source that can be opened, and the searches that could short-circuit the task are documented rather than hidden.
Frontier AI browsing systems can answer many questions by locating obvious keywords or matching information from highly ranked webpages. This project explores how to construct a research question that cannot be solved through a single search. The answer must remain short, stable and objectively verifiable, while the clues require the researcher to connect different people, dates, places, organisations, publications, events, records and quantities.
Design one difficult but fair browsing challenge.
A short, stable and objectively verifiable fact.
Every clue must be independently supported by reliable evidence.
A question, answer, clue set, source trail, validation log and JSON record.
AIBRC-001
Portfolio integrity note: Every claim on this page was checked against the cited source before publication. No source, quotation, locator or search result is invented; where a detail could not be verified directly it is described rather than quoted.
Begin with a stable fact that can be confirmed through a reliable primary or authoritative source. Record the exact wording, document title, issuing organisation and publication date.
Develop clues involving different fact types, including dates, people, places, organisations, works, events, records and quantities. Each clue must be independently checkable.
Run obvious, broad and targeted search queries. Record the results to identify accidental shortcuts, direct answer leakage and misleading pages.
Explain how each source supports a specific clue and how the clues logically combine to identify one answer.
Recheck every source, confirm answer uniqueness, document limitations and export the completed benchmark record in a consistent JSON format.
Each clue constrains the answer from a different direction. No single row is sufficient on its own, and every row can be checked against a source another researcher can reach.
Statuses are editable so the matrix can be worked through row by row. Scroll sideways on small screens.
| Clue ID | Fact type | Clue statement | Constraint | Supporting source | Exact locator | Verification status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C01 | Date | The cable in question was completed and landed in the first week of August 1858. | Fixes the year and narrows the event to a single summer. | HISTORY — This Day in History, 5 August 1858 | Article headline and opening paragraph | Verified |
| C02 | Person | The venture was driven by an American merchant who had pursued the crossing since 1854. | One named individual: Cyrus West Field. | Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable | Lead section, first paragraph | Verified |
| C03 | Place | Its two shore ends were an island off the west coast of Ireland and a bay in Newfoundland. | Resolves to Valentia Island and Bay of Bulls, Trinity Bay. | Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable | Lead section, first paragraph | Verified |
| C04 | Organisation | The cable was built by a company formed for that single purpose. | The Atlantic Telegraph Company, identifiable under that exact name. | Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable | Lead section, first paragraph | Verified |
| C05 | Publication or work | A weekly American science magazine devoted a long report to the cable later that same month. | Scientific American, issue dated 21 August 1858. | Scientific American archive — “The Atlantic Cable” | Issue date line, 21 August 1858 | Verified |
| C06 | Event | A reigning British monarch and a sitting American president exchanged inaugural greetings over it. | Queen Victoria and President James Buchanan; one dated exchange. | The Henry Ford — galvanometer artifact record | Artifact overview, object 149963 | Verified |
| C07 | Record or quantity | The link failed within weeks of carrying that exchange. | Rules out the later, durable 1866 cable. | HISTORY — “A Bold, Short-Lived Success” | Standfirst and opening paragraph | Verified |
Each card records a source that was opened and read before it was cited. Excerpts are quoted only where the wording was read directly; otherwise the record describes what the source shows.
A strong benchmark documents the searches a capable researcher or browsing agent would naturally attempt, including the ones that exposed the answer. Leakage is recorded rather than hidden, and the question is rewritten around it.
| Search number | Exact search query | Search engine or database | Date searched | Top relevant results | Answer revealed? | Problem discovered | Action taken |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S01 | first transatlantic telegraph cable 1858 Queen Victoria Buchanan message 16 August 1858 history | Web search | 4 September 2026 | atlantic-cable.com messages archive; Science Museum; IEEE Spectrum; Library of Congress guide; Wikipedia | Yes | The query itself contained the answer date, so snippets returned it directly. | Answer-bearing wording removed from the published question; the date is never named in any clue. |
| S02 | 1858 Atlantic cable USS Niagara HMS Agamemnon mid-ocean splice Valentia Trinity Bay landed August 5 | Web search | 4 September 2026 | Scientific American 1858 issues; HISTORY 5 August 1858; PBS American Experience; IET Archives | No | Results cluster on 5 August (completion), which is a plausible wrong answer for a careless solver. | Kept as a deliberate distractor; clue C01 states completion explicitly so the solver must notice the two dates differ. |
| S03 | "August 16, 1858" Queen Victoria President Buchanan telegram exchanged transatlantic cable | Web search | 4 September 2026 | The Henry Ford artifact 149963; Wikipedia; Library of Congress; FCIT USF | Yes | Exact-phrase search on the date confirms it instantly. | Used only as a verification search after the answer was fixed; recorded here for transparency. |
| S04 | 1858 Atlantic cable failed September 1858 stopped working weeks Wildman Whitehouse | Web search | 4 September 2026 | atlantic-cable.com Whitehouse material; Cambridge University Press chapter; HISTORY; IET | No | None — confirms the failure without dating the ceremonial exchange. | Retained as supporting evidence for clue C07. |
Every candidate source is scored from 1 to 5 against five criteria before it is allowed into the evidence chain.
Who created or issued the information?
Is the source directly connected to the event or record?
Does it support the precise claim being made?
Is the information unlikely to change?
Can another researcher locate the same evidence?
Export a report that maps every clue to the source it rests on, records the verification status and access date of each source, and lists the searches that exposed the answer.
Completion
14 of 15 checks confirmed
93%
The complete challenge is delivered as a single validated JSON document.
aibrc-001-benchmark-record.json
{
"challenge_id": "AIBRC-001",
"title": "AI Browsing Benchmark Research Challenge",
"project_type": "independent_demonstration",
"research_domain": "Nineteenth-Century Communications History",
"difficulty": "advanced",
"question": "A submarine telegraph cable finished in the summer of 1858 joined an island off the west coast of Ireland to a bay in Newfoundland, and stopped working within weeks. On what date did the reigning British monarch and the sitting American president exchange their inaugural greetings over it?",
"accepted_answers": [
"16 August 1858"
],
"answer_type": "short_text",
"answer_normalisation": {
"case_sensitive": false,
"ignore_punctuation": true,
"accepted_variations": [
"16 August 1858",
"August 16, 1858",
"16/08/1858",
"1858-08-16"
]
},
"clues": [
{
"clue_id": "C01",
"fact_type": "date",
"statement": "The cable in question was completed and landed in the first week of August 1858.",
"constraint": "Fixes the year and narrows the event to a single summer.",
"source": "HISTORY — This Day in History, 5 August 1858",
"locator": "Article headline and opening paragraph",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C02",
"fact_type": "person",
"statement": "The venture was driven by an American merchant who had pursued the crossing since 1854.",
"constraint": "One named individual: Cyrus West Field.",
"source": "Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable",
"locator": "Lead section, first paragraph",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C03",
"fact_type": "place",
"statement": "Its two shore ends were an island off the west coast of Ireland and a bay in Newfoundland.",
"constraint": "Resolves to Valentia Island and Bay of Bulls, Trinity Bay.",
"source": "Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable",
"locator": "Lead section, first paragraph",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C04",
"fact_type": "organisation",
"statement": "The cable was built by a company formed for that single purpose.",
"constraint": "The Atlantic Telegraph Company, identifiable under that exact name.",
"source": "Wikipedia — Transatlantic telegraph cable",
"locator": "Lead section, first paragraph",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C05",
"fact_type": "publication or work",
"statement": "A weekly American science magazine devoted a long report to the cable later that same month.",
"constraint": "Scientific American, issue dated 21 August 1858.",
"source": "Scientific American archive — “The Atlantic Cable”",
"locator": "Issue date line, 21 August 1858",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C06",
"fact_type": "event",
"statement": "A reigning British monarch and a sitting American president exchanged inaugural greetings over it.",
"constraint": "Queen Victoria and President James Buchanan; one dated exchange.",
"source": "The Henry Ford — galvanometer artifact record",
"locator": "Artifact overview, object 149963",
"status": "verified"
},
{
"clue_id": "C07",
"fact_type": "record or quantity",
"statement": "The link failed within weeks of carrying that exchange.",
"constraint": "Rules out the later, durable 1866 cable.",
"source": "HISTORY — “A Bold, Short-Lived Success”",
"locator": "Standfirst and opening paragraph",
"status": "verified"
}
],
"evidence": [
{
"evidence_id": "E01",
"claim_supported": "Supports C06 — the date of the inaugural exchange (the answer).",
"source_title": "The First Transatlantic Telegraph Cable Was a Bold, Short-Lived Success",
"issuing_organisation": "HISTORY (A&E Television Networks)",
"source_type": "News reports",
"url": "https://www.history.com/articles/first-transatlantic-telegraph-cable",
"publication_date": "Published 28 October 2021; updated 28 May 2025",
"page_number": "n/a (web article)",
"section": "Opening paragraph",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "High — established editorial outlet, corroborated by E02 and E03",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E02",
"claim_supported": "Corroborates C06 — same date, independent institutional source.",
"source_title": "Galvanometer Used to Receive Queen Victoria's Message to President James Buchanan Over the First Transatlantic Cable, 1858",
"issuing_organisation": "The Henry Ford (museum collection record)",
"source_type": "Institutional records",
"url": "https://www.thehenryford.org/collections/explore/artifact/149963",
"publication_date": "Undated collection record",
"page_number": "n/a (catalogue entry)",
"section": "Artifact Overview",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "High — object-level institutional catalogue",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E03",
"claim_supported": "Corroborates C06 — third independent statement of the same date.",
"source_title": "August 16: Transatlantic Telegraph",
"issuing_organisation": "Florida Center for Instructional Technology, University of South Florida",
"source_type": "Institutional records",
"url": "https://fcit.usf.edu/project/transatlantic-telegraph/",
"publication_date": "Undated educational page",
"page_number": "n/a (web page)",
"section": "Page introduction",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "Moderate — educational summary, useful only as corroboration",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E04",
"claim_supported": "Supports C02, C03 and C04 — company, leader and the two shore ends.",
"source_title": "Transatlantic telegraph cable",
"issuing_organisation": "Wikipedia",
"source_type": "Reference databases",
"url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transatlantic_telegraph_cable",
"publication_date": "Continuously revised",
"page_number": "n/a (wiki article)",
"section": "Lead section",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "Moderate — tertiary reference, never used alone",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E05",
"claim_supported": "Supports C01 — completion of the cable on 5 August 1858.",
"source_title": "First transatlantic telegraph cable completed — 5 August 1858",
"issuing_organisation": "HISTORY (This Day in History)",
"source_type": "News reports",
"url": "https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/august-5/first-transatlantic-telegraph-cable-completed",
"publication_date": "Published 9 February 2010; updated 28 May 2025",
"page_number": "n/a (web article)",
"section": "Opening paragraph",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "High — corroborates E04 on Field's role",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E06",
"claim_supported": "Supports C05 — contemporary periodical coverage.",
"source_title": "The Atlantic Cable",
"issuing_organisation": "Scientific American (archive)",
"source_type": "Primary sources",
"url": "https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-atlantic-cable-1858-08-21/",
"publication_date": "21 August 1858",
"page_number": "n/a (archive scan)",
"section": "Issue of 21 August 1858",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "High — contemporaneous publication",
"verification_status": "verified"
},
{
"evidence_id": "E07",
"claim_supported": "Supports C07 — the cable failed within weeks.",
"source_title": "The First Transatlantic Telegraph Cable Was a Bold, Beautiful Failure",
"issuing_organisation": "IEEE Spectrum",
"source_type": "Secondary sources",
"url": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-first-transatlantic-telegraph-cable-was-a-bold-beautiful-failure",
"publication_date": "Undated on the retrieved page",
"page_number": "n/a (web article)",
"section": "Headline and article body",
"access_date": "4 September 2026",
"reliability": "High — technical professional publication",
"verification_status": "verified"
}
],
"search_validation": [
{
"search_id": "S01",
"query": "first transatlantic telegraph cable 1858 Queen Victoria Buchanan message 16 August 1858 history",
"platform": "Web search",
"search_date": "4 September 2026",
"relevant_results": "atlantic-cable.com messages archive; Science Museum; IEEE Spectrum; Library of Congress guide; Wikipedia",
"answer_exposed": true,
"notes": "The query itself contained the answer date, so snippets returned it directly. Answer-bearing wording removed from the published question; the date is never named in any clue."
},
{
"search_id": "S02",
"query": "1858 Atlantic cable USS Niagara HMS Agamemnon mid-ocean splice Valentia Trinity Bay landed August 5",
"platform": "Web search",
"search_date": "4 September 2026",
"relevant_results": "Scientific American 1858 issues; HISTORY 5 August 1858; PBS American Experience; IET Archives",
"answer_exposed": false,
"notes": "Results cluster on 5 August (completion), which is a plausible wrong answer for a careless solver. Kept as a deliberate distractor; clue C01 states completion explicitly so the solver must notice the two dates differ."
},
{
"search_id": "S03",
"query": "\"August 16, 1858\" Queen Victoria President Buchanan telegram exchanged transatlantic cable",
"platform": "Web search",
"search_date": "4 September 2026",
"relevant_results": "The Henry Ford artifact 149963; Wikipedia; Library of Congress; FCIT USF",
"answer_exposed": true,
"notes": "Exact-phrase search on the date confirms it instantly. Used only as a verification search after the answer was fixed; recorded here for transparency."
},
{
"search_id": "S04",
"query": "1858 Atlantic cable failed September 1858 stopped working weeks Wildman Whitehouse",
"platform": "Web search",
"search_date": "4 September 2026",
"relevant_results": "atlantic-cable.com Whitehouse material; Cambridge University Press chapter; HISTORY; IET",
"answer_exposed": false,
"notes": "None — confirms the failure without dating the ceremonial exchange. Retained as supporting evidence for clue C07."
}
],
"quality_checks": {
"The answer is short and objectively verifiable.": true,
"The answer is supported by an authoritative source.": true,
"The question has only one defensible answer.": true,
"No single clue directly exposes the answer.": true,
"Each clue is independently checkable.": true,
"The clue set spans multiple fact types.": true,
"The task requires multi-step reasoning.": true,
"Obvious searches have been documented.": true,
"Search-result snippets do not reveal the answer.": false,
"Sources are publicly accessible.": true,
"Exact pages, tables or sections are recorded.": true,
"The evidence chain can be reproduced.": true,
"The question avoids subjective interpretation.": true,
"The answer is stable over time.": true,
"No fabricated evidence is included.": true
},
"researcher": {
"name": "TMK Research Lab",
"portfolio": "https://theophilusmorkporkpor.lovable.app",
"email": "tkudjordjie@gmail.com"
}
}AI-generated statements are never treated as evidence. Every factual claim must be verified against an accessible external source.
This benchmark is complete: the answer is fixed, 7 evidence records are attached to specific clues, and 4 validation searches are documented, including those that exposed the answer. It demonstrates the ability to approach an unfamiliar subject systematically, separate evidence from assumption and document research so that another person can audit it.
Two dates compete: the cable was completed on 5 August 1858 and the ceremonial exchange happened on 16 August. Much of the popular coverage leads with the earlier date.
Queries built around the ships and the mid-ocean splice returned rich material on the laying of the cable but nothing that dated the royal message.
The Henry Ford's catalogue record for the receiving galvanometer, because it ties the date to a surviving object rather than to press retellings.
The clue that the link failed within weeks rules out the durable 1866 cable, leaving one candidate event.
Answering “5 August 1858”, the completion date, or drifting to 1866 and reporting the first commercially successful cable instead.
The strongest dating evidence here is institutional and journalistic rather than an 1858 government document; a scan of the original telegram text would strengthen the chain.
Add an archived copy of each cited page and a digitised contemporary newspaper column carrying the full message text.
I am available for web research, fact-checking, AI evaluation, benchmark construction, source verification and structured research documentation.
TMK Research Labtkudjordjie@gmail.comhttps://theophilusmorkporkpor.lovable.apphttps://www.linkedin.com/in/theophilus-kudzordzi